I have to say it'll bomb.
Mainly because the guy we loved as Garfield, Lorenzo Music died.
Without that voice it won't work.
With cartoon/comic strips/comic books/toys live action movies, it can vary, a lot.
The "He-Man" movie is a hoot and a half, one of those corny movies we love to watch.
Spider-Man really took off.
But as was mentioned, "Rocky and Bullwinkle" tanked.
Hmmm......
What do you think, animated or live-action, UTLT or Nip n' Tuck?