I'm a little surprised at people's reaction to having a pope elected who wasn't pro-choice or in favor of homosexual marriage.

(If I thought there was any chance,
I would have busted my way into the conclave.) Also, I'm not terribly surprised that he, as a youth in Nazi Germany, was conscripted to serve in Hitler Youth and do some guard duty; I'd be more suspicious if he had somehow avoided it (but of course, then Dan Rather found documents written in the
Futurama "alien" language saying that he neglected his duties).
I'm definitely not a fan or sympathizer of the church (which is just a greedy, less-socially-responsible-than-most corporation, IMO), as I was raised Catholic in a church with a pedophile priest, a coverup, hypocrisy, etc. IMO, the church does no more good works than any corporation "gives" to the United Way by badgering their employees into making donation's in the company name. I did not hesitate at all to convert to Judaism (because I don't believe in the divinity of Jesus, either). The new pope is not relevant in my life, most-people's lives, or even the lives of many Catholics, and I'm sick to death of the coverage.
(Of course, that's not to say that I fault every individual Catholic for the failings, but (for now) let's just say I'm disappointed in some people's lack of free-thinking skills and ideas on what
loyalty forces them to accept.)
Actually, I'd compare the Catholic Church to the British monarchy, but I actually have respect for Queen Elizabeth, who didn't think she was above drving supply trucks for England's military during WWII.
Still, I'm not at all surprised that a conservative was chosen to lead the Catholic Church again. These are religious people, and if they believe that theirs is the only right way (or even if they're just calculating) then that's the kind of people they'll put in charge. And, even if the leadership doesn't realize the church's own irrelevance, most of the world does. They've held strong opinions about the sun orbiting the Earth and threatened death to Copernicus, but eventually they were shown up and had to adapt. Ideally, they would have stuck with their core beliefs and fallen into obscurity long before now, but instead they decided to change "just enough" over time to keep their membership, but not with the same amount of influence.
Basically, despite the hidden psychological meaning of my rant, the new pope doesn't have any real impact on our lives. Even when politicans try to buddy up with him, it's like anything else a politican says or does (outside of actually voting on legislation) -- superficial. So is the face of the Catholic Church.